Closing out a Cashless Consumption Position in PYPL

Closing out a Cashless Consumption Position in PYPL

Actions for this Week

The following are the changes in ratings or strategy we are making as of Friday February 26, 2016:

  • Following the sharp rebound in the stock market this week, and weakening economic and market fundamentals, we’re rating ProShares Short S&P 500 ETF ([stock_quote symbol=”SH”]) shares as a “Buy”.
  • Following PayPal /American Express rumors, we’re updating our PayPal ([stock_quote symbol=”PYPL”]) rating to “Sell”.

During the last few weeks, the stock market, as measured by the S&P 500, has undergone a powerful rally. As of last night, that market had climbed 8.6% from its Feb. 11 close. While we are enjoying the market’s move higher, the economic data has continued to point to a slower domestic and global economy. Examples include the following:

  • China’s official Purchasing Managers’ Index fell to 49.0 in February, marking the lowest reading since November 2011.
  • The Caixin/Markit Manufacturing PMI February reading for China dropped to 48.0, contracting for the 12th straight month.
  • China’s services sector continued to expand in February, but at its slowest pace since late 2008.
  • Euro-zone factory activity expanded at its weakest pace during the last year in February, with its manufacturing PMI falling to 51.2 from 52.3 in January.
  • Japan’s February PMI hit at 50.1 in February, down from 52.3 in January.
  • While a tad better than last week’s Flash February reading of 51.0, the final February manufacturing PMI reading for the United States fell to 51.3 from 52.4 in January. This marked the slowest increase in 28 months.
  • The ISM manufacturing perked up to a reading of 49.5, from 48.2 in January, but February was the fifth consecutive month with a reading in contraction territory. We’d note the last time this happened was during the 2009 financial crisis.
  • The domestic services economy edged down in February per the Institute for Supply Management and even the Fed’s Beige Book reported a “marginally weaker tone” in February than January.
  • Total U.S. carload traffic for January and February fell 13.5% year over year, according to data from the Association of American Railroads.

Taking all those data points together, along with those from January, tells us that the velocity of the global manufacturing economy slowed further in February. Quarter to date, the global economy appears to be hitting another speed bump. My concern is the increased probability of a repeat of what happened coming into 2016 — slow or weakening economic data, currency headwinds and cuts to earnings expectations.

Turning back to the stock market… the recent and welcome market rally has pushed the NYSE McClellan Oscillator (an indicator of market breadth based on the number of advancing and declining issues on the NYSE) even higher than last week and back to levels from which we’ve seen the market correct significantly.


In addition, as of last night, the S&P Capital IQ Short-Range Oscillator shows the market is now significantly overbought — two times overbought to be precise.

Conditions warrant staying cautious near-term

What this tells me is we once again are back in cautious territory and that means that not only are the ProShares Short S&P 500 ETF ([stock_quote symbol=”SH”]) shares a buy at current levels, but we need to be cautious when adding new positions in the short-term as well. Our current thematically driven and dividend-heavy portfolio has served us well in 2016, allowing us to easily outperform the market indices.

Given the increasing probability that growth and earnings expectations will need to be revised lower yet again, amid the current overbought nature of the market, my plan is to keep these more defensive positions in Aging of the Population play Physicians Realty Trust ([stock_quote symbol=”DOC”]), Connected Society play AT&T ([stock_quote symbol=”T”]), Guilty Pleasure investment Philip Morris International ([stock_quote symbol=”PM”]) and Content is King holding Regal Entertainment Group ([stock_quote symbol=”RGC”]) intact. Even American Capital Agency Corp. ([stock_quote symbol=”AGNC”]), with its monthly dividend stream and annual dividend yield at better than 13%, warrants holding as things are poised to once again get a little bumpy.

Here’s the thing — we’ll once again have a chance to buy thematically well-positioned companies at better prices and more compelling risk-to-reward trade-offs. Let’s not jump the gun, but rather be patient and prudent. As an experienced carpenter would say, “measure twice and cut once.”

Closing PYPL position post PayPal/American Express Rumors

The best performer over the last week has easily been PayPal ([stock_quote symbol=”PYPL”]) shares, which rose more than 5% to $38.80. That has our PYPL shares up 16.6% since mid-September vs. less than 1.7% for the S&P 500. Fueling the recent move in PYPL shares was a rumored tie-up between PayPal and charge and credit card company American Express ([stock_quote symbol=”AXP”]). However, Wall Street was very quick to shoot that rumor down. With takeout speculation abating and concerns over the direction of the market near-term, my thought is it’s better to take profits and look to buy PYPL shares back at better prices. Long-term, I continue to like the company’s position as a standalone play for our Cashless Consumption investing theme. Therefore, we are updating our rating on  Paypal to “Sell” at this time.

About the Author

Chris Versace, Chief Investment Officer
I'm the Chief Investment Officer of Tematica Research and editor of Tematica Investing newsletter. All of that capitalizes on my near 20 years in the investment industry, nearly all of it breaking down industries and recommending stocks. In that time, I've been ranked an All Star Analyst by Zacks Investment Research and my efforts in analyzing industries, companies and equities have been recognized by both Institutional Investor and Thomson Reuters’ StarMine Monitor. In my travels, I've covered cyclicals, tech and more, which gives me a different vantage point, one that uses not only an ecosystem or food chain perspective, but one that also examines demographics, economics, psychographics and more when formulating my investment views. The question I most often get is "Are you related to…."

Comments are closed.