Weekly Wrap: Momentum is Going Up Up Up, Albeit With a Lot Less Conviction

Weekly Wrap: Momentum is Going Up Up Up, Albeit With a Lot Less Conviction

Due to travel logistics this week, we’re giving you a quick recap at the midweek before heading into the last hurrah of summer and the Labor Day holiday weekend in the United States.

  • Equity markets reaching new highs while economic data is mixed at best.
  • The market mistakes dialogue around trade negotiations for a fait accompli.
  • Ignoring the rising risks Italy presents isn’t making it go away.


You’ve heard this one before right? Equity markets making new highs while volatility continues to be exceedingly low. Here are a few thoughts as we exit the summer and head into the final months of the year.

  • The yield curve continues to flatten and yet few seem to care. This is nothing new as the same thing happened in 2000 and 2007. What’s old is once again new… again.
  • Market breadth is weakening. As I mentioned on this week’s Cocktail Investing podcast, only 2 of the 11 S&P 500 sectors are currently at new highs (Consumer Discretionary and Healthcare). Back in January, 7 sectors were at new highs. We also see fewer stocks making new highs than back in January.
  • Volume is also quite low at this time of year, so I would argue there isn’t a ton of conviction due to seasonality behind the recent new highs.
  • The Shiller PE ratio has risen to 32.2x. It has only been this high 3% of the time in the past 127 years. This metric has a terrible track record for timing, but has been quite good for forward overall market returns. If history is any guide, and it usually is, just buying the major indices and hoping for the best is likely going to disappoint at best. Specific security selection matters more now than at any time during this bull run, and we here at Tematica continue to favor our thematic approach. 
  • People keep talking about the forward PE being reasonable at 17x and 16x for all of 2019. Hold on a minute. That is dependent on 10% EPS growth in 2019, which seems unlikely because…
  • Corporate profits as a percent of GDP remain well above historical norms. In the first quarter, S&P 500 operating earnings rose 25% year-over-year versus 5.4% nominal GDP growth. Normally these two are within a few percentage points of each other – not 20% apart!
  • The S&P 500 dividend yield is now less than the 3-month Treasury. Recall that from 2010 to mid-2016 the dividend yield was on average, roughly 2% more. TINA (There Is No Alternative) has left the building.
  • The spread between the 10-year and the 2-year Treasury bond is below 0.2. Historically when this drops to zero, a recession isn’t too far away.

Narrowing breadth, profit levels elevated relative to historical norms and future growth expectations highly optimistic – the risk that the market will be disappointed in the coming months looks pretty high to me.


The Economy

The economic data continues to be a mixed bag, but more data is coming in weaker than expected than is coming in better than forecast. The Economic Research Institute’s Leading Economic Index has declined in 5 of the past 6 weeks and is not at its lowest point for the year. Market reaching new highs while the LEI hits a 2018 low – the markets and the economy often don’t accurately reflect one another.

One of the biggest geopolitical risks continues to be these ongoing trade wars. This week looks to have made progress with Mexico and maybe Canada, but, and for the life of me I don’t know why this isn’t discussed more, Congress still has to vote on these agreements and I wouldn’t exactly describe the relationships on Capitol Hill as warm and fuzzy. We’ve also got mid-term elections coming up with a decent probability that the Democrats are going to gain ground, which means inside the beltway would be even more cantankerous. 

As for those trade wars and revised terms with Mexico and Canada, they pretty much translate into higher prices for consumers. So, the big question is with consumer spending accounting for around 70% of GDP, will any gains in wages (which has so far been rather elusive) be sufficient to make up for rising prices thanks to new terms of trade and the overall rising costs we’ve been hearing about?

Then there is Italy. No one seems to be paying much attention to the fact that the third largest economy is Europe is having a political meltdown. I’d like to point out that more people died in Rome this year from accidents largely due to the utterly horrendous roads than died in the bridge collapse in Genoa. On a side note, I’ll be back in Genoa next week. I get a massive lump in my throat when I think what it will be like to drive past the collapsed bridge. Italy’s political leadership has been giving social media more mockery material than I would have ever dreamed, or perhaps that’s more of a nightmare. This situation is going to get much, much uglier and then there is that Brexit mess. But markets are making new highs so, it’s all good. 


The Bottom Line for the Week

It’s all about momentum and the momentum is going up, up, up, albeit with a lot less conviction than I’d like to see. The economic and geopolitical picture when one looks out beyond the next six months makes me want to distract myself by uncorking a nice Barolo. That said, Labor Day weekend is upon us so go enjoy the sun, your friends, your family, and think of all for which you can be grateful. Eat a bit too much. Laugh a bit too much. Life is sweet and all too short. Enjoy.

During next week’s four trading days, we’ll be looking for the ISM Manufacturing and non-Manufacturing Indices and motor vehicle sales as well as the productivity numbers for Q2 and July Factory Orders. We’ll also get August’s payroll reports and average hourly earnings.


About the Author

Lenore Hawkins, Chief Macro Strategist
Lenore Hawkins serves as the Chief Macro Strategist for Tematica Research. With over 20 years of experience in finance, strategic planning, risk management, asset valuation and operations optimization, her focus is primarily on macroeconomic influences and identification of those long-term themes that create investing headwinds or tailwinds.

Comments are closed.