Currency Wars – It's On!

2015-01-26 Currency WarLast Wednesday the European Central Bank (ECB) announced that it is launching its own quantitative easing program that was double what had been rumored, at an impressive €1.2 trillion. ECB Chairman Mario Draghi was able to pull off a program of this size by having some 80% of the bond-buying executed by national central banks. The agreement is that Germany will only buy German government bonds, France will only buy French bonds and so on. This was key to getting the program approved because if Spain or Italy goes off the rails, the German Bundesbank’s balance sheet won’t be immediately devastated. This is the main driver behind the rally in German bonds beyond the periphery bonds, which is also driving the rally in US bonds, as the markets can’t indefinitely maintain such a large spread between the only perceived risk-free rates left!

Despite all the rhetoric concerning how the economy is so very ship shape and all is going well on at least this side of the Atlantic, last year the best performing sectors were defensive ones: utilities and healthcare. This year with the crash in oil prices, the energy sector is forced to significantly delay capital expenditures and will by necessity put downward pressure on wages. Gasoline and diesel prices across the US have now fallen for a record 16 straight weeks. For the rest of the economy, the threat of global slowing and deflation may make many businesses hesitant to invest aggressively in expansions.

Central bankers across the globe have been on the frontlines of the newest form of international altercations, currency wars, which is driving yields into truly bizarre territory. Two weeks ago the Swiss National Bank removed the three-year currency cap on the franc and cut key rates having told the market just a month earlier that there were in fact no plans to remove the cap, sending markets into a veritable tizzy. India cut its key rate by 25 basis points and Bank of Korea lowered its outlook. Last week the Bank of Canada surprised everyone by lowering its main interest rate by a quarter percentage point for the first time since 2009. In Japan, Bank of Japan Governor Kuroda cut the nation’s core inflation forecast to 1% from 1.7%. Earlier last week the International Monetary Fund cut its forecast for inflation in advanced nations almost in half.   The result of these moves has left the Swiss 10-year yield in negative territory, the German 10-year at 0.52%, the French 10-year at 0.70% and the Japanese 10-year at 0.23% given that expected rates of inflation are all above these levels in their respective nations, 10-years in much of the develop world are now in negative real yield territory.   The currency war is on!

Those negative real yields reflect that most European countries are in or nearly in a recession. Italy for example is in a recession for the third time in six years, suffering from a 9% drop in output since 2008, and with unemployment increasing steadily from 7.8% in 2009 to 13.4% in November 2014. The ECB is expected to inject a massive monetary stimulus in an attempt to bolster the economies of these beleaguered nations, but the root of the problem isn’t monetary, thus the solution cannot solely be monetary. For example, in the January 10th edition of the Economist, Rwanda, which was in a bloody civil war just 20 years ago, is now cited to be a better place to do business than Italy! (Remember how we earlier mentioned that it is easier to start a business in Italy than in the U.S.?) No amount of monetary stimulus can fix those structural problems.

So we have defensive sectors outperforming and a material decline in trading volume, which tells you that investors are nervous.   Which brings us to the recent turn around in the yellow metal. Gold has traditionally had an inverse relationship with the dollar. For example, over the past four years the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD) has had a -0.45 correlation with the Amex Dollar Index (DXY). From December 15th through yesterday, that correlation had completely reversed to be 0.75.   In 2015 so far, the correlation has been a mind-boggling 0.84! That’s a nearly perfect positive correlation. With central bankers around the world under pressure to manipulate their currency so as to inflate asset prices rather than having elected politicians deal with the very real structural problems, we believe it is no surprise to see gold once again showing strength. It has long been viewed as one of the only reliable stores of value and as long as the currency wars wage, will likely show continued strength, albeit with bumps along the way.

About the Author

Lenore Hawkins, Chief Macro Strategist
Lenore Hawkins serves as the Chief Macro Strategist for Tematica Research. With over 20 years of experience in finance, strategic planning, risk management, asset valuation and operations optimization, her focus is primarily on macroeconomic influences and identification of those long-term themes that create investing headwinds or tailwinds.

Comments are closed.